Clown and Cactus
Yep, I got sucked in by a food promotion. It's nothing new for me, but some of the recent Seattle collaborations have me intrigued. As a kid, once I'd seen the “Big Mac Attack” commercials, the little cheeseburger in my Happy Meal just didn't cut it anymore, toy or no toy.
This time the hook was subtler. I was listening to the Gee and Ursula Show when they mentioned that Pagliacci and Taco Time had teamed up on a pizza-taco hybrid, and the servomechanism in the reptilian part of my brain locked in. One way or another, I was going to have a slice.
I have fond memories of both places. The companies are doing just fine, but the particular locations I frequented in my youth, in the University District and Wallingford, are gone.
First, the pizza. I'm embarrassed to admit that in my early teens, my go-to pizza on The Ave was the Godfather's Pizza all-you-can-eat buffet: food that tasted like it came out of a microwave, despite the late Herman Cain's best efforts as CEO to put a spin on it. Discovering the Pagliacci next door was a breath of fresh air.
Pagliacci was founded in 1979 by Dorene Centioli-McTigue, who grew up in Garlic Gulch, Seattle's unofficial Little Italy, and started it with her brother and cousin. The name comes from Ruggero Leoncavallo's opera Pagliacci (“Clowns”), basically a love triangle in which a clown murders his wife and her lover. The walls were covered in Italian-language movie posters, many of them for American films. It seemed like such a cool place that I applied for a job there. The manager took one look at my clean-cut appearance and asked whether I'd mind if all my coworkers had green hair and nose rings. I probably wasn't hip enough to fit in.
Not being cool enough to work there didn't stop me from eating there and dragging my friends along. I once brought two former coworkers, both genuine New Yorkers, one Italian and one Puerto Rican, who wore handkerchiefs in the pockets of their perfectly laundered suits and were always happy to critique bland West Coast cuisine. Even they gave it their seal of approval.
Now, the taco. Taco Time was started by Ron Fraedrick in Eugene, Oregon, in 1960. Before you accuse me of embracing the Ducks, there's a catch: Frank Tonkin Sr. opened the first Washington Taco Time in White Center in 1962, and in 1979 the Western Washington restaurants became their own independent company, Taco Time Northwest. So the Taco Time in The Dalles that was hit in the 1984 Rajneeshee salmonella attack, directed by the infamous Ma Anand Sheela, belonged to a completely separate operation.
The Wallingford Taco Time had character. It was a mirrored glass cube, reportedly designed by architect Felix Misch with input from owner Jon Hanna, with the trademark cactus sign, high ceilings, and a neon clock announcing ANYTIME IS TACO TIME. Set against an overcast Seattle sky, it became a minor legend, earning affectionate nicknames like “Disco Taco Time”,"Bauhaus Taco Time" and my favorite, “Blade Runner Taco Time.” I also always seemed to come out ahead at their drive-through. The employees made errors in my favor, and who's going to complain about finding an extra order of Mexi-Fries in the bag when they get home?
Both of those locations are gone now. The original Pagliacci on The Ave closed in 2018, and the Wallingford Taco Time followed in 2024 (it's a Chipotle now). So going to a Pagliacci in Bothell for a slice of the limited-edition Taco Time pizza was really a tribute to two places that have given me good memories over the decades.