Walking the Plank at the Northlake
Denied! I should have known better.
The plan was to try Big Mario's bread bowl pizza with Ivar's clam chowder, with the goal of knocking out two collaborations before the end of the week. What I'd forgotten was that my go-to Big Mario's, the one on Northlake Way, closed back in 2024. Google pointed me to the one in Ballard, but for me that's practically a road trip requiring an itinerary. The building is still there, and my brain keeps filing it under "pizzeria," because a pizzeria should be there. One was, for nearly seventy years.
Before Big Mario's, that spot was the Northlake Tavern & Pizza House, an institution. I was introduced to the idea of the Northlake by a twenty-something substitute teacher in sixth grade. I don't remember him teaching us anything, but he loved talking to us about two things: Woody, the breakout new character on Cheers, and the best pizza in Seattle. To try that one, he told us, we'd have to wait until we were twenty-one. That kind of mythology, planted in the minds of '80s kids, is why so many twenty-first birthday runs in the '90s started there.
It would be intellectually dishonest to claim I was ever a regular. But the place definitely had character: classic pizzeria tablecloths, leather chairs, and a history to match. The embryonic stage, it sat by the Ship Canal Bridge opened my Hazel Miller in the 1930s. Herb and Evelyn Friedman bought it in 1953 and moved it to Northlake Way the next year. It was still just a tavern until 1960, when Herb, a Brooklyn native, started serving pizza, as the legend goes, the first non-Italian restaurant in Seattle to do so.
David Horsey's cartoons covered the walls, and the menu was a gem of artistic ingenuity in its own right. The Combo featured an anthropomorphic sausage and mushroom shredding on electric guitar and banjo. If ordering the Vegetarian made you feel any less manly, a showgirl-styled tomato and green pepper were there to assure you that you'd made a fine choice. And of course, the Maui had a hula dancer.
Yes, there were regulars. Every time I went, I'd hear about some customer who'd been coming since the 1970s. They usually didn't have much to say about their lives since then, but at least they had good taste.
I was never going to become one of those people. I lacked the metabolism. This wasn't a place you dropped by for a slice. The pies were thick and heavy. There was the Meat Eaters, and then there was the Logger. I always pictured someone yelling "Timber!" right before a pizza heavy enough to kill you came crashing down. A trip to the Northlake wasn't casual. You went with an eating agenda, and that meant recruiting others to come along.
None of that meant I'd miss the last weekend. Even Horsey was in line, and you bet I wanted to be seen. That last Saturday, my spot was inching toward the door when a vicious rumor worked its way back: they'd run out of pizza. Most people wanted proof. It was true, but it didn't stop me from having one last beer. Chef Abdoullah, the final owner, who'd been mentored by Herb Friedman himself, was making the rounds shaking hands. I normally have two beers, but whispers started that a private party was about to begin. When pirates on motorcycles started rolling up, I took the hint. As a Seattleite, I'm fluent in subtle hints, and these guys didn't strike me as the passive-aggressive type if I overstayed my welcome.
There was plenty of enthusiasm when Big Mario's opened, but to me it tried a little too hard to recreate the old atmosphere. Yes, I had a drink by myself in the David Horsey VIP Room while waiting on my order, just so I could say I did. But that's the only real memory I have of the place.
Which is my reminder not to try to recreate the past, especially when the past is closed.